Single choice · #323
The principal said to Teacher Wang, who had proposed a teaching improvement plan: "Are you on the side of our school, or on the side of the rival school?" Which of the following responses by Teacher Wang most effectively dismantles this false dilemma?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: C
- AOf course I'm on our school's side—do you even need to ask?✗ Choosing "our school's side" outright concedes that there are only two possible positions—being with our school or with the rival—thereby falling into the principal's false dilemma without challenging its premise.
- BWell, first tell me: which side do you think I'm on?✗ This counters with a question, deflecting the choice temporarily, but it fails to point out that other positions exist; it only delays taking a stance without truly breaking the dilemma.
- CMy proposal aims to make our school better—this isn't a matter of taking sides.✓ Stating that the goal is to improve the school introduces an independent objective that is neither siding with our school nor with the rival, effectively adding a third option and directly negating the necessity of the either-or framing.
- DThe rival school could never come up with such an improvement suggestion.✗ This tries to prove loyalty by disparaging the rival, but it still assumes that only two camps exist and shifts focus to comparing camps rather than discussing the improvement itself, thus missing the core issue.
Explanation:The principal's question re-frames the "improvement proposal" as a matter of taking sides. Teacher Wang clearly identifies the goal as 'making the school better,' which is neither siding with the rival nor blindly supporting the school. This introduces a third option into the discussion and therefore most effectively dismantles the false dilemma. The other options either accept the binary choice or avoid the question without challenging the structure of the dilemma.