LogicTest
English
Log inSign up

QuestionsMeans and Ends

Single choice · #347

A department head emphasized at a meeting that 'everyone should save company funds,' but afterward, he ordered high-end office furniture for himself and insisted on staying at luxury hotels during business trips. Employees are privately discussing this. Which of the following evaluations is most accurate?

Show answer & explanation

Answer: C

  • AThe supervisor's personal consumption is a private right, separate from the work requirement to save.✗ Incorrect. When the supervisor's personal consumption involves the use of company resources, it is no longer purely a private matter; this option evades the institutional consequences of inconsistent words and actions.
  • BEmployees should focus on the rules themselves, not on the supervisor's personal life.✗ Incorrect. Employees are not concerned with the supervisor's private life but with the actual behavior modeled by the supervisor; focusing only on slogans and ignoring actions overlooks the psychological mechanism that affects the institution.
  • CThe supervisor's words and deeds contradict each other; employees will see saving as just a slogan, and trust in the institution will be undermined.✓ Correct. The goal is to make employees save, but the means demonstrate wasteful behavior; employees act according to what is actually rewarded, and the institution loses credibility.
  • DThe supervisor's extravagance is meant to motivate employees to work hard; the saving requirement can be implemented later.✗ Incorrect. Using 'motivation' as an excuse turns the means into the opposite of the goal and delays its achievement; this directly conflicts with the goal of having employees save.
Explanation:In the stem, the supervisor's public requirement is to save, but actual behavior is wasteful. The divergence between goal and means leads employees to lose trust in the institution—they see the behavior being modeled, not the slogan being promoted. The correct option reveals the specific mechanism of inconsistency between words and actions; the distractors confuse the core contradiction with 'private rights,' 'focusing on rules,' and 'motivation excuse.'
‹ PreviousNext ›

More questions on this topic

Ms. Qin is a financial advisor who wants the industry and her clients …
Single choice
A woman repeatedly posts photos of luxury restaurants, designer bags, …
Single choice

Means and Ends: guide & sample questions → · 3 questions on this topic

This is a public sample question. Sign up to practice the full bank: a timed set of 10 questions in 10 minutes, with per-option reasoning for every question.

Take the test